Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Michael Haupt's avatar

Excellent list! I know how long it takes to not only put together, but to find these initiatives in the first place and then cohere them into some sort of meaningful framework—well done!

If I may comment on one angle that seems to be missing. For that I need a bit of an analogy. All religions have their artifacts. Artifacts from one religion are meaningless in another. Religions are a belief system. Capitalism is a belief system. Capitalism has artifacts (markets, money, material goods and a supply chain).

The list you have compiled represents an alternative belief system to Capitalism. Many of them still rely on the artifacts of Capitalism. In other words, they are still dependent on the belief system they claim to transcend. At best they can be more effective. At worst they are hypocritical.

This is part of the lack of coherence we've discussed elsewhere. It's a tricky one to resolve, and I'm not suggesting there is a 'right' or 'wrong' way here. All I can do is point out the incoherence, and since you have a marketing slant, you'll understand why this is important. It's part of what I'm trying to address in my own Substack.

Let's tackle this thorny challenge in unison!

Expand full comment
Random Thought Generator's avatar

Thank you for sharing this list. I’m a nomad myself, and community has been feeling rather elusive lately.

Expand full comment
33 more comments...

No posts